2002 - 2004: Stanford University
Becoming Human: The Evolutionary Origins of Spiritual, Religious and
Moral Awareness
Abstract
2003-2004 Lectures and Activities
2002-2003 Lectures and Activities
2001-2002 Lectures and Activities
Project Leaders
Organizing Committee/Working Group
Additional Information
Abstract
As the modern world converges on a globally standard material culture built
on scientific technology, questions of the significance of religious and moral
traditions become ever more important. Through much of the 20th century two
currents ran at cross-purposes setting the stage for our present dilemma. On
the one hand, the recognition of the astonishing variability of human customs
and cosmologies reported by anthropological studies challenged us to reappraise
the meaning of being human. We began to recognize cherished truths -- religious
and moral -- as just another set of tribal traditions. At the same time a revolution
in the human sciences was building, based on the unifying principle of evolutionary
theory. By the end of the century the idea of biologically fundamental human
nature began to reemerge. But now religion came under attack from another direction.
Theories of sociobiology and evolutionary psychology challenged the notion that
religious and moral ideas were anything but agents of adaptation in the service
of genetic self-interest, with no foundation in a transcendent source.
Today new theories and tools of investigation are, for the first time, beginning
to make possible a unified approach to the coevolution of genetics and culture
and a more integrated understanding of what it means to be human. This allows
us to reconsider the origins, development and significance of spiritual and
moral beliefs and practices. It also permits us to view these beliefs in a way
that can defend human dignity and diversity while preserving global community
and cooperation. In a three year project entitled "Becoming Human: The
Evolutionary Origins of Spiritual, Religious, and Moral Awareness," we
propose to convene a committee of distinguished scholars from diverse disciplines
to initiate an ongoing interdisciplinary (and inter-religious) program that
will include both academic inquiry and scientific research. Regular monthly
meetings, with presentations and open discussions along an ordered schedule
of topics, will culminate each Spring Quarter in a series of lectures or a conference
open to the entire academic community and general public. Themes for each of
the three years can be outlined as follows:
Origins: We will begin with a consideration of the origins
and adaptive significance of our capacities for spiritual, religious, and moral
thought. Exploring these foundations, through the lens of paleoanthropology,
archaeology and comparative ethology, we will seek to redescribe and redefine
these capacities in a way that recognizes both their biological utility and
their implications of greater ontological significance. Most specifically, we
will consider the role of religion in the cultural continuity, transition and
transformation that allows on-going progress in the flourishing of human life.
Mechanisms: During our second year, we will discuss the genetic,
neural and developmental basis of human spiritual, religious and moral capacities.
We will consider the meaning of our particular embodied form and the relational
dynamics of human life that make possible consciousness, communication, and
moral community. Likewise, we will discuss the significance of our questing
nature, the drive to form a comprehensive and coherent understanding of reality
(what has been called the "cosmological imperative"). Of greatest
significance, we will discuss our capacities for freedom and imagination thatallow
us to transcend the forces of physico-chemical determinism with images and aspirations
that lift us beyond the imperatives of the "real" to the aspirations
of the ideal.
Prospects: In our final year we will return to the fundamental
questions of origins, but this time recognizing the "ongoing origins,"
the ever-emerging creation and extension within the evolutionary process. From
this view, issues of direction and purpose may reemerge together with questions
concerning a divine source of both the creation and destination of life. Such
an approach, that takes seriously the physical world, may recognize within the
phenomenon of life (and its extensions in human technology) a rising scale of
freedom and peril, and the crucial significance of questions concerning human
meaning and purpose.
Through this three-year investigation we hope to approach a richer integration
of an evolutionary understanding of the natural world and its relationship to
the source and significance of our spiritual, religious and moral capacities.
Recognized as both an imperative of adaptation and a beckon to transcendence,
our moral and spiritual inclinations toward the good, the beautiful and the
tru are appreciated as both in the service of life and life itself.
Goals: It is our hope that this interdisciplinary dialogue
will serve as the beginning of a long term initiative in the integration of
biology and matters of religious and ethical significance. Our goal is to stimulate
academic interest and nourish creative interdisciplinary collaboration in both
intellectual inquiry and scientific research. In addition, we will provide a
mediation of these important issues for general education, through lectures,
conferences, publications, internet, and radio and television programs, and
as applicable to political and social policy discussions relevant to our subject.
It is our intention that this approach will foster open and creative dialogue
and lead to innovative research, significant publication and exciting extensions
in both the classroom and long-term student honors projects and dissertations.
The main intellectual legacy of the grant, however, will be two things: an edited
volume of our second year conference proceedings together with other notable
presentations from the lecture series, and most importantly, the ongoing interdisciplinary
program in biology, religion and ethics.
top
2003-2004 Lectures and
Activities
May 21st-22nd, 2004
Conference: Becoming Human - Future Prospects
The Evolution of Humans: Are We Thinking Too Narrowly?
Simon Conway Morris, Ph.D.
Professor of Evolutionary Paleobiology, University of Cambridge
Ecology and Religion: The Big Step From Function to Meaning
William Durham, Ph.D.
Bing Professor of Human Biology, Stanford University
Society, the Individual and Mass Killing: Reflections on a Century of Genocide
and Ethnic Cleansing
Norman M. Naimark, Ph.D.
Robert and Florence McDonnell Professor of East European Studies, Stanford University
Discussion
Moderated by William
B. Hurlbut, M.D.
Consulting Professor in the Program in Human Biology, Stanford University
Is There Purpose in the Universe? Questions to Cosmology, Biology and Theology
John F. Haught, Ph.D.
Landegger Distinguished Professor of Theology, Georgetown University
Evolution and the Future of Humanity
Simon Conway Morris, Ph.D.
Professor of Evolutionary Paleobiology, University of Cambridge
Panel Discussion
Moderated by William
B. Hurlbut, M.D.
Consulting Professor in the Program in Human Biology, Stanford University
top
2002-2003 Lectures and
Activities
May 24, 2003
Conference: From Biology to Biography - The Science of the Human Person
Session I Biology: Chemicals to Consciousness (i.e. the phylogeny of
personhood)
The Evolutionary Foundations of Freedom, Mind and Moral Awareness
William
B. Hurlbut, M.D.
Consulting Professor in the Program in Human Biology, Stanford University
Why and When are We Emotional
Paul Ekman, PhD
Professor of Psychology, University of California, San Francisco
The Embodied Mind: The Ground of Concepts
George Lakoff, PhD
Professor of Linguistics at the University of California at Berkeley
Evolution, Empathy and Human Intersubjectivity
William
B. Hurlburt, M.D.
Consulting Professor in the Program in Human Biology, Stanford University
Session II: Biography: Personal Identity, Social Community and Spiritual
Cosmology (i.e. the ontogeny of the human person)
The Development of Moral Understanding, Emotion, and Identity through Life
Anne Colby, PhD
Senior Scholar at the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching
I Lost my Head: Awareness, Emotion and Choice
Paul Ekman, PhD
Professor of Psychology, University of California, San Francisco
The Embodied Mind: Central Metaphors of Moral and Spiritual Life
George Lakoff, PhD
Professor of Linguistics at the University of California at Berkeley
Faculty Seminar
- Discussion of Hans Jonas' essay, Philosophical Aspects of Darwinism.
This philosophically rich article initiated a discussion of the nature of
description of the organic in biology with its view from the outside and its
treatment of the organism as machine.
- Discussion of Leon Kass’ The Hungry Soul: Eating and the Perfecting
of Our Nature.
- Wide-ranging discussion on the moral community and the criteria for inclusion.
Readings included: a paper co-written by animal rights activists and British
research scientists exploring concept of mind and its applicability to non-human
species as well as the ethical implications of any conclusions drawn; a selection
from Alasdair Macintyre’s Dependent Rational Animal; a selection
from Descartes’ Discourse on Method; several short aphorisms
from Wittgenstein; and an article by Daniel Dennett on Conditions of Personhood.
- Discussion of Antonio Damasio’s book Looking for Spinoza, focused
primarily on exploring the distinction Damasio draws between “feeling”
and “emotion.”
- Discussion of George Lakoff and Mark Johnson’s Philosophy in the
Flesh, concerning their theory of metaphor and the potential epistemological
limits it places on human knowledge.
Becoming Human: The upper division undergraduate course at Stanford
The seminar course, co-designed and co-taught by William Durham and
William Hurlbut, attempted to introduce undergraduates to some of the scientific
questions and ongoing investigations in this important area. Many of the texts
that had been discussed in the faculty seminar were included in the undergraduate
course. The course as originally conceived was to be a ten to twelve student
seminar. We had, however, such an overwhelming interest (over sixty students
signed up for the course), that we expanded it as much as possible, and allowed
thirty-five students to enroll.
top
2001-2002
Lectures and Activities
May 17th-18th, 2002
Conference: Becoming Human - The Evolutionary Origins of Spiritual, Religious,
and Moral Awareness
Making Meaning: Ice Age Art, Spirituality and Religion
Margaret Conkey, PhD
Class of 1960 Professor of Anthropology, UC-Berkeley
Director, Archaeological Research Facility
Human, All Too Human
Robert Hamerton-Kelly,
ThD
Former Dean of the Chapel, Stanford University
The Evolutionary Emergence of Moral Cognition
Terrence Deacon, PhD
Professor of Biological Anthropology, Boston University
Darwin's Cathedral: Evolution, Religion and the Nature of Society
David Sloan Wilson, PhD
Professor of Biology and Anthropology, Binghamton University
Human Relations and Religious Faith
René Girard, PhD
Andrew B Hammond Professor (Emeritus) of French and Comparative Literature,
Stanford University
Faculty Seminar
- Discussion of Walter Burkert's Creation of the Sacred, on the the
interrelations of biology and religion.
- Talk by Professor Wentzel van Huyssteen (Princeton Theological Seminary)
on the productive relationship between the anthropological sciences and religious
studies.
- Discussion of articles by the paleontologist Ian Tattersal. One was a short
article, published in Zygon, in which he presents a critique of the
evolutionary psychology; the other was a chapter on the question of human
uniqueness from his book Monkey in the Mirror.
- Discussion of the cultural vs. biological explanations for the incest taboo,
led by William Durham (co-director of the Becoming Human project) and Stanford
Cultural Anthropology professor Arthur Wolff.
- Discussion of Terrence Deacon’s book, The Symbolic Species,
concerning complex language as the clearest and most immediate example of
a uniquely human behavior.
- Discussion, led by Professor René Girard, of his book Sacred
Violence, concerning his theory of mimetic rivalry and violence.
top
Project Leaders
William B. Hurlbut, M.D.
Physician and Consulting Professor in the Program in Human Biology, Stanford
University
Born in St. Helena, California, he grew up in Bronxville, New York. After receiving
his undergraduate and medical training at Stanford University, he completed
postdoctoral studies in theology and medical ethics, studying with Robert Hamerton-Kelly,
the Dean of the Chapel of Stanford, and subsequently with the Rev. Louis Bouyer
of the Institut Catholique de Paris. His primary areas of interest involve the
ethical issues associated with advancing biomedical technology, the biological
basis of moral awareness, and studies in the integration of theology and philosophy
of biology. His courses in biomedical ethics in the Program in Human Biology
include: “Adam 2000: Images of Human Life in the Age of Biomedical Technology”
and “Ethical Issues in the Neurosciences.” He has also taught a
course on genetics and human origins with Dr. Luca Cavalli-Sforza, Director
of the Human Genome Diversity Project and a course on epidemics, evolution and
ethics with Dr. Baruch Blumberg who received the Nobel Prize for discovery of
the Hepatitis B Virus. Since 1998, he has been a member of the Chemical and
Biological Warfare working group at the Center for International Security and
Cooperation and has worked with NASA on projects in astrobiology. In 2001 he
was appointed by President George W. Bush to the President’s Council on
Bioethics.
William Durham, Ph.D.
Bing Professor of Human Biology, Department of Anthropological Sciences, Stanford
University
William Durham joined the Stanford faculty in 1977 and has just completed
a term as Chair of the Department of Anthropological Sciences. Professor Durham’s
main research interests are in ecology and evolution, the interaction of genetic
and cultural change in human populations, and the challenges to conservation
and community development in the Third World. His field studies among the
San Blas Kuna of Panama have involved investigation of demography, genetics,
and resource management. He has also researched the causes of land scarcity
and environmental degradation in rural El Salvador and Honduras and the social
forces behind deforestation in Mexico and Central and South America. Professor
Durham’s publications include Scarcity and Survival in Centeral
America (Stanford Press, 1979); Coevolution: Genes, Culture, and
Human Diversity (1991); and The Social Causes of Environmental Destruction
in Latin America (with M. Painter, Michigan, 1995). During his tenure
at Stanford, Dr. Durham has received the Gores, Dinkelspeil, ASSU, Rhodes,
and Bing Fellow Awards for his teaching. His work has been supported by the
National Science Foundation, H. F. Guggenheim Foundation, Danforth Foundation,
and MacArthur Foundation. Dr. Durham was a Fellow at the Center for Advanced
Study in the Behavioral Sciences from 1989 to 1990. He served as the Director
of the Human Biology Program at Stanford from 1992 through 1995, and he is
currently editor of the Annual Review of Anthropology. Professor
Durham earned his Ph.D. from the University of Michigan.
top
Organizing Committee/WorkingGroup
Click on the name of a conference member for biographical information.
- Baruch Blumberg, Director of the
NASA Astrobiology Institute
- Luca Cavalli-Sforza, Professor
of Genetics Emeritus, Stanford University
- William Damon, Professor of Education
and Director of the Center on Adolescence, Stanford University
- William Durham (co-Principal Investigator),
Bing Professor of Human Biology, Stanford University
- Arnold Eisen, Professor of Religious
Studies, Stanford University
- Paul Ekman, Professor of Psychology,
University of California, San Francisco
- Marcus Feldman, Burnet C. and Mildred
Finley Wohlford Professor in the School of Humanities and Sciences and Professor
of Biological Sciences, Stanford University
- John Gabrieli, Associate Professor
of Psychology, Stanford University
- René Girard, Andrew B. Hammond
Professor of French Language, Literature, and Civilization Emeritus, Stanford
University
- Robert Hamerton-Kelly, Pastor,
Woodside Village Church
- John F. Haught, Thomas Healey Distinguished
Professor, Georgetown University
- William Hurlbut (Committee Chair
and co-Principal Investigator), Physician and Consulting Professor in the
Program in Human Biology, Stanford University
- William L. McLennan, Dean of Religious
Life, Stanford University
- William C. Mobley, Chair, Department
of Neurology, Stanford University
- Simon Conway Morris, Professor of
Evolutionary Paleobiology, University of Cambridge
- Norman M. Naimark, Robert and Florence
McDonnell Professor of East European Studies, Stanford University
- Bill Newsome, Professor of Neurobiology,
Stanford University
- Andrea Nightingale, Associate
Professor of Classics and Comparative Literature at Stanford University
- V.S. Ramachandran, Professor
of Neuroscience, University of California, San Diego
- Robert Sapolsky, Professor of
Biological Sciences, Stanford University
- Jeffrey Schloss, Professor of Biology,
Westmont College
- David Spiegel, Professor and Associate
Chair of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, Director of the Psychosocial Treatment
Laboratory, and Medical Director of the Complementary Medicine Clinic, Stanford
University School of Medicine
- Lee Yearly, Chairman, Department
of Religious Studies, Stanford University
top
Additional Information
Becoming Human Project Website
http://www.metanexus.net/becoming_human/index.html
Contact:
William B. Hurlbut, M.D.
Stanford University
Program in Human Biology
Bldg 80, Room 110
Mail Code 2160
Stanford, CA 94305-2160
Work: 650.725.2610
Fax: 650.725.5451
ethics@stanford.edu |
William Durham, Ph.D.
Stanford University
Anthropology Department
Building 360
Mail Code: 2117
Stanford, CA 94305-2117
Work: 650.723.0867
Fax: 650.725.9996
EB.WHY@stanford.edu
|
top
|